A Savage Art: The Life and Cartoons of Pat Oliphant
(7/10)
by Tony Medley
88 minutes.
In theaters
This provides an interesting background to political
cartoonists. For example, it claims that Benjamin Franklin created the
first political cartoon, featuring a snake cut into pieces, with the
caption "unite or die" underneath. For that, he's considered America's
first political cartoonist.
It also states that, in this day and age, as well as for
hundreds of years, visuals communicate immediately. And at the right
time and the right place. It tells about Thomas Nast. In the 1870s, he
was the highest-paid entertainer-journalist in the world. Because of an
illiterate population, he could connect with them through his drawings.
He was massively popular, drawing for Harper's Weekly. He invented Santa
Claus. He invented the donkey and the elephant as political symbols. He
is widely credited with putting the corrupt Boss Tweed in jail. He put
the caricatures of Boss Tweed and his gang on the heads of vultures.
People saw that, and he was turned out of office. Tweed said, “I don't
care a straw for your newspaper articles; My constituents don't know how
to read, but they can't help seeing them damn pictures!” Boss Tweed died
in prison, and in his collection of works, in prison, was every Thomas
Nast cartoon ever done on him.
However, this is primarily a documentary about left-wing
cartoonist Pat Oliphant. Oliphant’s second wife is quoted as saying that
there are three things in a cartoon. First, the idea, second, the image
(an idea that has to register), then the caption that’s funny. She is
quoted as saying that he said he almost never got all three.
Along with telling the story of how Oliphant got to be the cartoonist he
became, Oliphant bragged that he “wasn’t afraid of taking on the Reagan
Administration for their role in bringing the world to the brink of
nuclear war and nuclear Armageddon.” Unfortunately, this paints him as a
leftwing puppet who didn’t realize that Reagan was winning the Cold War
without firing a shot.
He must have been a constantly unhappy man, saying, “You
gotta wake up every morning angry” and “The thing a cartoonist does for
other people is, he articulates their hate.”
Directed by Bill Banowsky (from a script by him, Paul
O’Bryan, and Dean Alioto), a liberal known for his film “Starving the
Beast,” a documentary critical of conservative political efforts that
tries to emphasize the negative effects of Republican ideological
conflict targeting traditional liberal arts, this doc is ringingly
left-wing. Most of the people interviewed are liberals, like Ann Telnaes
of the Washington Post, former Democratic Senator Tom Udall, and
cartoonist Adam Zyglis.
A New York Times headline is shown, reading, “Pittsburgh
Post-Gazette Cartoonist fired as Paper Shifts Right.” Yet there is no
mention of the Los Angeles Times’ firing of Conservative cartoonist
Michael Ramirez in 2005 because of his political slant. And Ramirez is
available to interview as he publishes in the Las Vegas Review-Journal
and is syndicated by Creators Syndicate.
Apparently, only leftwing cartoonists need apply for this
film because the only cartoonist interviewed who doesn’t have their feet
planted securely on the left is Tom Gibson, who was on the staff of the
Reagan White House, and if you blink, you miss him.
Cartoonist Adam Zyglis passionately defends cartoonists'
right to “express their voice,” but only, apparently, if their “voice”
is left-wing.
Although the film is politically biased, it remains
interesting and features numerous great cartoons.
Tony Medley is an attorney, columnist, and MPAA-accredited film critic
whose reviews and articles may be read in several newspapers and at
rottentomatoes.com, CWEB.com, robinhoodnews.com, Movie Review Query
Engine (mrqe.com), and at
www.tonymedley.com.
A former sports editor of the UCLA Daily Bruin, he is the author of four
books, UCLA Basketball:The Real Story, Sweaty Palms: The Neglected Art
of Being Interviewed, the first book ever written on the interview for
the interviewee, having sold over a half million copies, and The
Complete Idiot's Guide to Bridge, which has sold over 100,000 copies,
and Learn to Play Bridge Like a Boss. He is an American Contract Bridge
League RubyLife Master and an ACBL accredited director. He is a Mensa
Life Member and a member of the International Society of Philosophical
Enquiry, ISPE (“The Thousand”). |